Write An Essay Contrasting Civil Law And Common Law

Common Law Civil Law Essay

CIVIL-LAW AND COMMON LAW TRADITION: A

COMPARATIVE APROACH

Civil law primarily contrasted against common law. The significant

difference is that, historically, common law was developed by

custom whereas civil law was developed by legal principles and the

interpretation of doctrinal writings rather than application of facts to

legal fictions. 'Common-law is extremely decentralized in terms of

the source of law (making place for evolving cultural changes) is

highly centralized in its administration because of the weight of

precedent. On the other hand, the civil-law which is centralized in

its source leaves from for a great deal of ad hoc interpretation.'

(Crump M.W.& Kahalas H. 1975). Therefore the civil-law is by its

nature more capable than the common-law and more adaptable to

changing situations.

The Other distinction between the common law and civil law

systems is that the role of precedent has tended to become less

significant. Common law courts have developed skills in

distinguishing earlier judgments of which they disapprove and civil

law system, precedents have a value. Civil law countries try to

ensure that there is some certainty in the law and the same issue

will be decided in the same way. Civil law tradition prevents its

judges from establishing broad principles of law in the absence of

legislation. But in the common law system there is open possibility

for the same case.

'In civil law countries, legislation is seen as the primary source of

law. Thus, courts base their judgements on the provisions of codes

and statutes, from which solutions in particular cases are to be

derived.' (MacQueenH.L. 2000) By contrast, in the common law

system, cases are the primary sources of law, while statutes are

only seen as incursions into the common law and thus interpreted

narrowly.

Furthermore, separation of powers is differently in civil law and

common law countries. 'Some common law countries, especially the

United States, judge are balancing the power of the other branches

of government.'(Renz,D&John, E.C. 1985). By contrast, in civil law

countries judges are only applying the law. There are, however,

sociological differences. 'Civil law judges are usually trained and

promoted separately from attorneys, whereas common law judges

are usually selected from accomplished and...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

Common Law in Australia Essay

1090 words - 4 pages Common law is the law made by judges when deciding a certain case before the court. The reasoning the judge applies becomes a precedent, to be followed by other lower courts in future matters of similarity. This is the basis for the doctrine of precedent. A precedent is either a binding precedent, the reason for a decision of a higher court that must be followed by a court of lower status in the same hierarchy; or a persuasive precedent, meaning...

Sources of Common Law Essay

4071 words - 16 pages The question requires discussion of the sources of law in the United Kingdom (hereinafter referred to as UK) which comprises of common law, equity, legislation, European Union law and the European Convention on Human Rights. The UK is a stranger to codification of laws, hence it comes as no surprise that the UK does not have a written constitution. The English legal system comprises of two main sources of law. Primary sources of law cover...

Natural Law and Civil Law

963 words - 4 pages Leviathan as bearer of supreme authority and nationals who posses certain inalienable rights. We should draw attention to Hobbes’ reasoning about natural law and civil or positive law. According to Hobbes they both match with scope, form and content. However, natural law, which is impartial, equitable, legitimate, and moral in natural state is not the law itself; it just disposes people to peace, mercy, and obedience. Natural law is the laws that...

Comparison of common law and equity law

2888 words - 12 pages Originally, common law was customary law, folk law, based on precedent. There was of course statutory law -- the king's law -- but common law guided how it was enforced and administered. No real common law exists today, having been entirely codified as statutory law throughout the English-speaking world. There remains, however, what are sometimes termed common law rights.Now and again, a new situation arises where there is no law to...

Common Law vs. Political Law vs. Scientific Law

2135 words - 9 pages Common Law vs. Political Law vs. Scientific LawAmericans are no longer aware that there are two kinds of legal systems, political and scientific. America was founded on principles of scientific law. But these principles have now been submerged in today's legal system. What is taught today as law is political law.To understand the difference between a...

Civil procedure law reform

3488 words - 14 pages Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1934578 American Bar Association winter/spring 201111 Mediation and Civil Justice Reform in Hong Kong By Kun Fan Kun Fan is an assistant professor at the Chinese University of Hong Kong and a member of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators. She can be reached at kunfan@ cuhk.eduk.hk and thanks Cynthia Lee for her help in conducting research. In response to...

The Civil Law and The Religious Law

1194 words - 5 pages In the world the legal system are based on one of three basic systems. There is Western law which is divided into civil law and common law. Then there is Religious law. Each country has its own unique legal system that they include variations of civil, common and religious law. Some have a combination of all three. Civil Law are based on concepts, categories, and rules derived from Roman law, with some influence of canon law, sometimes largely...

Civil And Divine Law-antigone

986 words - 4 pages The Clash Between Civil and Divine Law      Charles Dickens once said, "The law is an ass." Though at first, it seems harsh and very strange, the deeper meaning is one that is a perfect summary of the Greek tragedy Antigone. The meaning of an "ass," is a stubborn, obstinate, perverse, immovable animal. Throughout Antigone, the characters must deal with the clash between Civil and Divine law....

History and Application of Common Law

1873 words - 7 pages 1a) Common Law, also widely known as Case Law, derived from the old English common law, is largely based on precedents, where judicial decisions were already previously made in similar cases where it is used as reference bases or sources of law. Also, common law is not codified, which generally means there is no comprehensive compilation of legal rules and not written in statues [The common law and civil law traditions, 2010:1]. It is during...

Criminal Conspiracy in Historical Common Law

1371 words - 5 pages Criminal Conspiracy in Historical Common Law The law of conspiracy is considerably more complex and uncertain than it need be because the statutory reform of the area largely contained in Part I of the criminal law Act 1977 was only partial. As a result, there are now two types of conspiracy – statutory conspiracies governed by the 1977 Act, and an important but limited range of common law conspiracies, which were expressly retained by the act,...

The Development of Common Law and Equity

3149 words - 13 pages The Development of Common Law and Equity 1.0 Introduction I have been asked to write a report on the development of common law and equity. Common law refers to the law created by judges that was historically significant but has been since superseded by parliament. It is in parallel with equity which refers to the source of law created by the Lord Chancellor which was designed to supplement the common law...

As lawyers know, legal systems in countries around the world generally fall into one of two main categories: common law systems and civil law systems. There are roughly 150 countries that have what can be described as primarily civil law systems, whereas there are about 80 common law countries.

The main difference between the two systems is that in common law countries, case law — in the form of published judicial opinions — is of primary importance, whereas in civil law systems, codified statutes predominate. But these divisions are not as clear-cut as they might seem. In fact, many countries use a mix of features from common and civil law systems. Understanding the differences between these systems first requires an understanding of their historical underpinnings.

The Historical Origins of Common and Civil Law Systems

The original source of the common law system can be traced back to the English monarchy, which used to issue formal orders called “writs” when justice needed to be done. Because writs were not sufficient to cover all situations, courts of equity were ultimately established to hear complaints and devise appropriate remedies based on equitable principles taken from many sources of authority (such as Roman law and “natural” law). As these decisions were collected and published, it became possible for courts to look up precedential opinions and apply them to current cases. And thus the common law developed.

Civil law in other European nations, on the other hand, is generally traced back to the code of laws compiled by the Roman Emperor Justinian around 600 C.E. Authoritative legal codes with roots in these laws (or others) then developed over many centuries in various countries, leading to similar legal systems, each with their own sets of laws.

If you are a working professional looking to expand your legal education, learn more about @WashULaw's online Master of Legal Studies degree.

Roles of a Lawyer and Judge in Each System

In civil law countries, judges are often described as “investigators.” They generally take the lead in the proceedings by bringing charges, establishing facts through witness examination and applying remedies found in legal codes.

Lawyers still represent the interests of their clients in civil proceedings, but have a less central role. As in common law systems, however, their tasks commonly include advising clients on points of law and preparing legal pleadings for filing with the court. But the importance of oral argument, in-court presentations and active lawyering in court are diminished when compared to a common law system. In addition, non-litigation legal tasks, such as will preparation and contract drafting, may be left to quasi-legal professionals who serve businesses and private individuals, and who may not have a post-university legal education or be licensed to practice before courts.

In contrast, in a common law country, lawyers make presentations to the judge (and sometimes the jury) and examine witnesses themselves. The proceedings are

then “refereed” by the judge, who has somewhat greater flexibility than in a civil law system to fashion an appropriate remedy at the conclusion of the case. In these cases, lawyers stand before the court and attempt to persuade others on points of law and fact, and maintain a very active role in legal proceedings. And unlike certain civil law jurisdictions, in common law countries such as the United States, it is prohibited for anyone other than a fully licensed lawyer to prepare legal documents of any kind for another person or entity. This is the province of lawyers alone.

As these descriptions show, lawyers almost always have a significant role to play in formal dispute resolution, no matter in which country they practice. But the specific tasks assigned to them tend to vary quite a bit. And outside the courtroom, tasks typically performed by lawyers in one country may be performed by skilled laypeople in another.

Each country has its own traditions and policies, so for those who wish to know more about the role of legal practitioners in a particular nation it is important to do additional research.

To provide readers with a jumping-off point, here are a few examples of countries that primarily practice common law or civil law.

Common Law Countries:

  • The United States
  • England
  • India
  • Canada

Civil Law Countries:

  • China
  • Japan
  • Germany
  • France
  • Spain

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *