Holocaust Research Paper Rubric 5th

Student Objectives

The Week Preceding the Unit

Session One: Introduction to the Holocaust

Session Two: Online Inquiry

Session Three: Focused Online Inquiry

Session Four: Oral Presentations

Session Five: Focused Group Inquiry

Session Six: Continued Group Inquiry

Sessions Seven and Eight: Publication

Extensions

Student Assessment/Reflections

 

STUDENT OBJECTIVES

Students will

  • read a range of Holocaust resources, from different genres and media.

  • use a variety of resources to gather and synthesize knowledge about the Holocaust.

  • work collaboratively to investigate questions about a specific topic.

  • present information orally and in a group newspaper.

back to top

 

The Week Preceding the Unit

  1. Each day, ask students to write a response to one of the prompts on the Journal Entries list, so that students have responded to all five prompts by the end of the week.

  2. Discuss responses as desired, but do not mention the connection to the Holocaust unit so that students are not tempted to make comparisons or guess the “right” response in connection to the forthcoming project.

back to top

 

Session One: Introduction to the Holocaust

  1. Begin this session by having the students discuss what it means to be a child, recalling entries that they’ve written in the journals over the course of the previous week as relevant. Guiding questions for the discussion might include:

    • What do you remember most about your childhood?

    • Did you have a special place?

    • What kinds of things were you afraid of?

    • What helped you feel safe?
  2. Read Chana Byers Abells’s The Children We Remember.

  3. After you read, facilitate a brief discussion by asking students to compare the lives of the Jewish children during the Holocaust to their own lives today. Encourage students to consider both the details from the images and the statements from the text.

  4. Tell students that you will be sharing another text about the Holocaust. Read “First They Came for the Socialists” by German Lutheran Pastor Niemoller.

  5. Write “innocent bystander” on the board and ask students to freewrite, connecting the words “innocent bystander” to the content of the poem.

  6. Have a few students share their writing and have a discussion on roles we play in intense situations. (You may bring up bullying or crime as examples.)

  7. Connect the class discussion to the journal entries from the previous week on bullying and standing up for others.

  8. If desired, present background information on the Holocaust, using the background notes or similar information from a class text.

back to top

 

Session Two: Online Inquiry

  1. Divide students into small groups and ask each group to compile a list of things that they know and things that they want to find out about the Holocaust, using the K-W-L Chart.

  2. Then ask students to explore the Holocaust Websites and to use Internet search engines to pursue answers to their questions.

  3. Remind students to record their new learning in the last column of the K-W-L Chart.

  4. As students work, circulate through the classroom, answering questions and providing help.

back to top

 

Session Three: Focused Online Inquiry

  1. Answer any questions students have from the previous session.

  2. Direct students to the Online Holocaust Inquiry page and explain the options for each of the sites.

  3. Depending upon your class time, ask students to pursue their research on the Holocaust by completing one or more of the activities listed.

  4. Encourage students to explore additional options and activities as well. Welcome additional projects or customizing of the ideas to fit students' interests.

  5. Allow students the remainder of the class session to pursue their questions.

  6. As students work, circulate through the classroom, answering questions and providing help.

  7. With approximately five minutes remaining in the session, pass out the rubric and explain that students will present one of their projects to the class during the next session.

  8. Answer any questions about the oral presentations.

back to top

 

Session Four: Oral Presentations

  1. Allow students several minutes at the beginning of the session to prepare their presentations.

  2. Spend the remainder of the class session asking students to each present one of their projects to the class.

  3. Use the rubric to assess oral presentations.

  4. For homework, ask students to reflect on their research and the projects that have been presented in their journals or writer’s notebooks. Responses should focus on issues that sparked students’ interest and questions that still linger in their minds about the Holocaust.

back to top

 

Session Five: Focused Group Inquiry

  1. Begin the session by asking students to share the questions and interests they recorded in their homework writing.

  2. As students share ideas, record the ideas on the board or chart paper.

  3. After students have offered their reflections, explain that students will have a chance to work in small groups to investigate a Holocaust topic in more detail and that they will publish their findings in a focused newspaper or similar format.

  4. Read back over the list of topics and issues recorded during the session, and ask students if they have any additional topics that they want to add to the list (e.g., Jewish laws, propaganda, Hitler youth, Kristallnacht, Non-Jewish Holocaust victims, Ghettos, concentration camps, liberators, and the aftermath).

  5. Ask students to choose one of the available topics and arrange them into groups based on their choices.

  6. Pass out a piece of chart paper to each group, or ask students to work in their notebooks.

  7. On the chart paper or in their notebooks, each group of students should write their topic at the top.

  8. Ask groups to brainstorm questions to guide their research, listing the questions on their chart paper or in their notebooks.

  9. If students need an example to guide their brainstorming, share the following example, for the group exploring the role of the liberators in the Holocaust:

    • What resistance occurred inside the camps themselves? Outside the camps?

    • Who were some of the rescuers of Jewish people (individuals, groups, and countries)?

    • Who are the “righteous gentiles”? Who are same famous ones?

    • What was the affect on liberators?
  10. Assist any groups that have a difficult time devising questions.

  11. Once students have collected their initial research questions, share the additional resources that are available for their inquiry project, including items from the Text Resources for Groups list.

  12. Explain that students should create a bibliography of the sources that they explore as they work, providing instruction from the Purdue Online Writing Lab as necessary.

  13. Using both print and online sources, students can spend the remaining time researching their topic.

  14. Encourage students to find at least one visual and one primary source as they complete their research.

  15. If appropriate, take advantage of the opportunity for a minilesson on the difference between primary and secondary sources.

back to top

 

Session Six: Continued Group Inquiry

  1. Remind students of the resources that are available for their inquiry project and answer any questions that they have.

  2. Explain that students will be producing their focused newspaper during the next session, so they should use the current session to complete their research and begin planning their presentation of the information that they’ve found.

  3. Allow students the remainder of the class session to pursue their questions.

  4. As students work, circulate through the classroom, answering questions and providing help.

back to top

 

Sessions Seven and Eight: Publication

  1. Explain that during the next two sessions, groups will create a newspaper filled with articles focusing on their specific topic.

  2. Ask students to prepare a group newspaper and a complete bibliography of the resources that they used to gather information.

  3. Ask each group member to write at least one article about their topic.

  4. Pass out the Newspaper Rubric and explain the requirements of the final project.

  5. To help students with planning, suggest that they spend one session creating their drafts and the second session working on layout and publishing their work.

  6. Demonstrate the Printing Press, which students will use to publish their group newspaper.

  7. Explain that group members will work together on revision, edit, layout, and publishing their newspaper.

  8. Ask students to print a copy of their newspaper for everyone in the class.

  9. Allow for a sharing time for students to present and distribute copies of their newspapers.

back to top

 

EXTENSIONS

  • Read Terrible Things: An Allegory for the Holocaust by Eve Bunting, or a similar book, to conclude the unit, discussing the book and making comparisons to other things they have seen and read throughout the unit. You can find additional texts on the Holocaust Book and Movie List.

  • Supplement the lesson plan with The Holocaust: Studying Lessons of the Past, a ReadWriteThink lesson plan further using the book Terrible Things.

  • Have your students read or listen to additional stories from Holocaust survivors .

  • Ask students to turn their attention to a social action project, which extends the lessons:

    1. Visit the Jewish Steven Spielberg Film and Video Archive and select one or more movies to play for the class.

    2. Maintain silence in the room.

    3. When the movie ends, write the words “What now?” on the board as a prompt.

    4. Ask the students to reflect on the question, “Now that I know what I know about the Holocaust, what now?” in their journals or notebooks.

    5. Once students have had adequate time to gather their ideas, ask students to share their reflections with the class.

    6. Based on the suggestions that students have made, choose one or more projects that students can complete to extend the project and their exploration of the Holocaust further. If desired, students can visit Tolerance.org for more information about fighting bigotry and intolerance on many topics.

back to top

 

STUDENT ASSESSMENT/REFLECTIONS

  • Evaluate students’ participation during group discussions to assess the development of critical thinking skills, during discussion, group projects, research, and writing.

  • Evaluate the oral delivery of group presentations, using the rubric.

  • Evaluate group newspapers using the Newspaper Rubric.

back to top

The website category is the most interactive of all NHD categories. A website should reflect your ability to use website design software and computer technology to communicate your topic’s significance in history. Your historical website should be a collection of web pages, interconnected by hyperlinks, that presents both primary and secondary sources and your historical analysis. To engage and inform viewers, your website should incorporate interactive multimedia, text, non-textual descriptions (e.g., photographs, maps, music, etc.), and interpretations of sources. To construct a website, you must have access to the Internet and be able to operate appropriate software and equipment.

How is a Website Different from Other Categories?

Websites can display materials online, your own historical analysis as well as primary and secondary sources. Websites are interactive experiences where viewers can play music, look at a video or click on different links. Viewers can freely navigate and move through the website. Websites use color, images, fonts, documents, objects, graphics and design, as well as words, to tell your story.

  • Research your topic first. Examine primary and secondary sources. From this research, create your thesis. This will be the point that you want to make with your historical website.
  • Narrow in on the content of your website. Decide what information you want to incorporate in your web pages, such as any photos, primary documents, or media clips you may have found. You should be sure to have plenty of supporting information for your thesis.
  • Create your website with the NHD Site Editor.Click here to begin the registration process.
  • Consider organization and design.
    • Keep it simple: don’t waste too much time on bells and whistles. Tell your story and tell it straight.
    • Borrow ideas from other websites: find design elements that work and imitate them on your website. Just remember to give credit where credit is due.
    • Make sure every element of your design points back to your topic, thesis, and/or time period. There should be a conscious reason for every choice you make about color, typeface, or graphics.

PLEASE NOTE – If you converted your website to save from previous contest years, you will need to use a new email address to create an account for the 2015 contest. The email address is optional and only used to recover passwords in the event of forgotten or lost passwords.

With so many complaints in the past regarding the Scrib.d element on NHD Weebly, we have removed this element and recommend students post their bibliographies and process papers as PDF files on their websites, using the ‘File’ element under ‘Media’. Please visit the following website created by former NHD participant, Christopher Su, for helpful tips and guides: NHD Website Resources

If you have any further questions please email IT@nhd.org with your current URL and login information. If you have lost your login information, cannot convert your standard Weebly to NHD Weebly, or need an account recovered please email nhdsupport@weebly.com.

A process paper is a description of how you conducted your research, developed your topic idea, and created your entry. The process paper must also explain the relationship of your topic to the contest theme. For more information on the Process Paper and other rules, review the Contest Rule Book (English) / Contest Rule Book (Spanish).

National Contest Student Website Examples

Junior Group

Senior Group

Senior Individual

China's Surge into Silk: The Exploration, Encounter, and Exchange of the Silk Road

Tigan Donaldson & Brian Ely

The Visionary Exploration of Jacques Cousteau: Changing Perceptions of the Ocean through Undersea Encounters

Sovigne Gardner & Grace Gardner

Ada Lovelace, The Enchantress of Computing: Exploring the Beginnings of the Information Evolution

Denisse Cordova

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *